An answer for an enduring question barzin pakandam abstract easter island is the most isolated inhabited spot on earth, devoid of heavy timber and most resources. Jun 23, 2012 diamond s examination of easter island once again demonstrates that culture cannot survive without nature. A number of scholars and researchers, particularly jared diamond author of collapse, 2006, developed and promoted the collapse theory of. What are the main points of diamonds argument about the. In just a few centuries, the people of easter island wiped out their forest, drove their plants and animals to extinction, and saw their complex society spiral into chaos and cannibalism. This work is triggered by jared diamond s 2005 popular book and brander and taylors 1998 economic model of easter island. The collapse of easter island by jared diamond this reading is taken from a chapter in diamond s 2005 book. Collapse book summary, by jared diamond allen cheng. Father sebastian englert william mulloy, translator and editor island at the center of the world, new light on easter island 19651970 this book both confirms and give the lie to jared diamond s collapse. The myths of easter island jared diamond responds mark. Transfiguration by annie dillard who killed easter. Imagine that you arrived on the island before the tree. The myths of easter island jared diamond responds mark lynas.
Island without trees as jared diamond tells it in his bestselling book, collapse, easter island is the clearest example of a society that destroyed itself by overexploiting its own resources. Easter island rapa nui has become widely known as a case of eco cide, where the ancient. Jared mason diamond born september 10, 1937 is an american geographer, historian, anthropologist, ornithologist, and author best known for his popular science books the third chimpanzee 1991. Rano raraku is the volcanic quarry on easter island. These are ancient wonders of the world that are still being studied to get a full understanding of how and why these statues were created. The discovery the island gets its name from its discovery by the dutch explorer jacob roggeveen, on easter april 5 in 1722. As jared diamond tells it in his bestselling book, collapse, easter island is the clearest example of a society that destroyed itself by. His technical research focuses on biological membranes, ecology, and evolutionary biology, especially of bird faunas of new guinea and other southwest pacific islands. In his hook collapse, jared diamond describes an ecological catastrophe brought on by the island s inhabitants that led to their own destruc. How societies choose to fail or survive for the british edition is a 2005 book by academic and popular science author jared diamond, in which the author first defines collapse.
Rapa nui, or easter island as it was named by 18th century. Describe several factors that contributed to the extinction of trees on the island. Collapse jared diamond 20321 from the author of guns, germs and. In jared diamond s twilight at easter, we travel across the mysterious easter island as he describes the most intriguing fact about this place.
Diamond identifies five factors that contribute to collapse. Easter island collapse disputed by hawaii anthropologist. In his runaway bestseller guns, germs, and steel, jared diamond brilliantly examined the circumstances that allowed western civilizations to dominate download the ebook collapse how societies choose to fail or succeed in pdf or epub format and read it directly on your mobile phone, computer or any device. Easter island can be used as a warning that cultural and environmental dangers exist due to overexploitation. How societies choose to fail or succeed and from an article in discover magazine. In the article, who killed easter island by jared diamond he states that people can affect and destroy our environment and natural resources. Ppt collapse of easter island powerpoint presentation. Selection file type icon file name description size revision. Easter hland, or rapa nui as it is known to the island s native polynesians, has also become the poster child for what happens when socie llts squander their resources and destroy their environment. Originally trained in biochemistry and physiology, diamond is known for. Their movement from quarry to erection site required so many trees for logs and rope making that deforestation was complete by 1400 to 1600 ad. You should probably read this about collapse jared diamond. Easter island was divided into a dozen clan territories that started at the coast, with statues and long homes for the elite, and stretched inland, where peasants farmed.
Easter island really does look and feel like an ecocatastrophe. This week i wrote a blog post reexamining the historical evidence for the view that what happened in prehistoric easter island is a classic story of ecological collapse and thereby holds lessons for us all. Collapse by jared diamond the flame by unite youth dublin. The article describes the former abundance of trees and forests on easter island. A system dynamics model representing the resource and population sectors of easter island has been built based on allocation of labor. Easter island s end by jared diamond, published in the discover magazine on august 1995, provides insight into how an increased population and rapid deforestation impair the sustainability of the environment. Among the most riveting mysteries of human history are those posed by vanished civilizations. My main hope is that we learn from the fates of societies like easter s. Another island, easter island, rapa nui, has 400 stone statues representing a legless human male torso, mostly 15 to 20 feet tall, with the largest 70. These are some of the key questions jared diamond endeavours to answer in his. Get an answer for who has the stronger argument on easter island between patricia a. To begin with, the island is the most remote habitable scrap of land in the world. Since then ive gotten to know jared diamond and mark lynas, so i wound up in the middle of their backandforth.
Islanders did succeed in getting enough water for drinking, cooking, and growing crops, but it took effort. Geologically one of the youngest inhabited territories on earth, easter island, located in the. Jared diamond, who used the easter island story as the lead case study in his 2005 book collapse, responds to the charge below. A contradictory account has been advocated over the past decade by a group of scholars, led by the anthropologists carl lipo and. Jared diamond has written a book to help us do the same. Twilight at easter is about a similar rise and fall in a much smaller area, a 66 square mile island. Tragically, it was statue building that seems to have lead to easter island s collapse. Yet, the first european travellers to the island marvelled at large and delicately carved statues covering the whole of the island. Easter island, with an area of only 64 square miles, is the worlds most isolated scrap of habitable land. New details on the island s chronology, settlement patterns, subsistence systems, and environmental change have led researchers to question ecocide, instead raising alternatives to scientific and public audiences e.
What happened on easter island a new even scarier scenario. We originally, from a further distance, have considered the said easter island as sandy, the reason for that is this, that we counted as sand the withered grass, hay, or other scorched and burnt vegetation, because its wasted. Adapted from jared diamond, easter s end, discover, august 1995, 168, pp. Download collapse book summary, by jared diamond as pdf. Environmental damage, climate change, globalization, rapid population growth, and unwise. One reason he selected this case is it proves to be the closest. A free powerpoint ppt presentation displayed as a flash slide show on id. Rethinking jared diamonds collapse of easter island. Easter island is famous for its tightlipped statues that stand across the island, which were erected by the rapa nui people between the 10th and 16th centuries ad. Transfiguration by annie dillard who killed easter island. The prevailing account of its prehistory, offered by jared diamond among others, has been that the island s first inhabitants wiped themselves out, committing ecocide by cutting down all the island s trees, spending precious time and resources carving and transporting moai, and fighting wars among themselves. Add to this the dramatic problem of overpopulation as in easter island and the result is impending disaster. Mar 25, 2004 the archaeologist jo anne van tilburg, the leading authority on the statues themselves, has used her understanding of easter island history and statues in her biography of the remarkable selftrained archaeologist and ethnographer katherine routledge, who spent seventeen months on the island in 19141915, and whose unpublished handwritten field notes van tilburg deciphered. Such a speculative exercise, given the limited information about.
Read a quick 1page summary, a full summary, or watch video summaries curated by our expert team. The pacific ocean, the pitcairn islands, and easter island 8485 the pitcairn. Selection file type icon file name description size revision time user. Part of this popularity comes from the work of jared diamond via his various essays e.
The recipient of numerous awards, he has published more than 200 articles in such prestigious magazines as discover and nature. Poor agricultural practices such as massive deforestation are the primary causes of resource depletion. According to diamond, the people of easter island destroyed. He notes the devastating blows inflicted on the tribes as they experienced the loss of raw materials, wildcaught foods, and the decrease in crop yields as soil fertility declines. Unlike the easter islanders, we have histories of the pastinformation that can save us. The island s 11 clans, which had originally traded amongst themselves in what diamond called miniglobalization to obtain the materials for the.
Mother tongue by amy tan summer reading assignment steps. Pulitzer prize winner jared diamond speaks on environment. Diamond has done his homework, and goes deep into the more subtle elements of the entire collapse cycle. In just a few centuries, states jared diamond, the people of easter island wiped out their forest, drove their plants and animals to extinction, and saw their. Jared diamond, professor of physiology at the ucla school of medicine, is the pulitzer prizewinning author of guns, germs, and steel. Diamond called this selfdestructive behavior ecocide and warned that easter. The prevailing account of its prehistory, offered by jared diamond among others, has been that the island s first inhabitants wiped themselves out, committing ecocide by cutting down all the island s trees, spending precious time and resources carving and transporting. Diamond argues that the people of easter island essentially abused their environment. Pdf easter island, the key to south america jacques. Environmental damage, climate change, globalization, rapid population growth. This study is devoted to answering this one remaining mystery.
Jun 01, 2020 this was outlined by jared diamond s book in 2005 called collapse who postulated the culture was on the decline by the 1600s. Diamond, easter island s end, discover magazine, august 1995. Easter island s end by jared diamond, in discover magazine august 1995 in just a few centuries, the people of easter island wiped out their forest, drove their plants and animals to extinction, and saw their complex society spiral into chaos and cannibalism. Diamond weaves an allencompassing world thesis through a series of fascinating historicalcultural narratives. In a recent essay in science, jared diamond 2007 reiterated the account given in his book. Collapse 2005, the world until yesterday 2012, and upheaval 2019.
Pdf easter island the name is synonymous with mystery, intrigue of archaeology, and today an. The island of rapa nui easter island, chile is just 161 km2 with a resident population of about 6600. By 1722, the island s population was estimated to be 2,0003,000. Guns, germs, and steel 1997, awarded a pulitzer prize. It lies in the pacific ocean more than 2,000 miles west of the nearest continent south america, 1,400. Moving from the polynesian cultures on easter island to the flourishing american civilizations of the anasazi and the maya and to the doomed viking colony on greenland, diamond traces the basic pattern of catastrophe. Jared diamond s argument about the society of easter island is laid out in chapter 2 of this book. Dec 11, 20 easter island is only 63 square miles in area and sits over 2,000 miles from the nearest country of chile. A dozen other polynesian societies, including those of henderson island and necker island and prebountymutineer pitcairn island, collapsed so completely that no human remained alive. In his book collapse, jared diamond describes an ecological catastrophe brought on by the. I forgot the words to the national anthem by james seilsopour 4. Who has the stronger argument on easter island between. Others, such as the societies of easter island and new zealands south island, did decline drastically in human numbers and complexity but continued to exist. Diamond for an aquatic species a lake or river is a distributional island surrounded by a sea of land.
In a recent essay in science, jared diamond 2007 reiterated the account. The incredible survival of rapa nui chapter understanding. Once tree clearing started, it didnt stop until the whole forest was gone. May 11, 2016 the first account, popularised by jared diamond in his bestselling book collapse 2005, presents the island s history as a cautionary tale of the destructive potential of humans to overexploit natural resources. Want to get the main points of collapse in 20 minutes or less.
This was outlined by jared diamond s book in 2005 called collapse who postulated the culture was on the decline by the 1600s. The worst insult that an easter islander could say to another easter islander was the flesh of your mother sticks between my teeth. I was there a few years ago and felt devastated by what i saw. Yet the easter island that he viewed was a wasteland with not a single tree or bush over 10 feet tall plates 6, 7. It lies in the pacific ocean more than 2,000 miles west of the nearest continent south america, 1,400 miles from even the nearest habitable island pitcairn. In jared diamond s followup to the pulitzerprize winning guns, germs and steel, the author explores how climate change, the population explosion and political discord create the conditions for the collapse of civilization. Diamond calls this ecological selfdestruction ecocide and offers rapa nui as a parable for our current global environmental crisis.
Mcanany questioning collapse and jared diamond collapse. Using a vast historical and geographical perspective ranging from easter island and the maya to viking greenland and modern montana, diamond traces a fundamental pattern of environmental catastropheone whose warning signs can be seen in our modern world and that we ignore at our peril. The island society collapsed in an epidemic of cannibalism. For me, jared s summary about easter island in his 2007 paper in science remains definitive for now. Print use the website link at the top of this page, print the passages in the summer reading list. There was a proliferation of more than stone buildings 2 m in height, described in oral tradition as chicken houses. Lessons from rapa nui easter island, chile for governance in. There are 397 stone statues found around and inside the volcano. Polynesian settlers reached easter island roughly 1,000 years ago give or take 500 years, depending on whose theory you believe via canoe. Among all such vanished civilizations, that of the former polynesian society on easter island remains unsurpassed in mystery and isolation. Although, civilizations have vanished from the island it still has a remaining mystery. How societies choose to fail or succeed titled collapse.
680 480 1523 1007 626 773 794 1315 1733 608 1345 834 1538 503 1473 317 1479 464 1308 194 1687 1485 844 18 1459 1431 1417 677 769 1526 1431 1347 1185 564 1474 601 895 610